Real estate disputes

Set aside a bailiff auction and restored the client’s ownership of a half share in an apartment

Bailiffs arranged the auction of our client’s half share in an apartment. Key documents concerning seizure, valuation and sale were sent to addresses where the owner did not live, even though the bailiffs knew he was incarcerated. The share was sold to a third party. We challenged the sale. The court found substantial procedural violations, invalidated the auction of 14 February 2023 and the sale agreement of 14 March 2023, and ordered the restoration of Nikolay Shchechkin’s ownership of the half share. The claim was granted in part: the court did not find the challenged actions of the state property agency unlawful. The published information does not confirm whether the restored right has been registered in the property register or whether the judgment has entered into force.

Situation

Bailiffs arranged the auction of our client’s half share in an apartment.

Key documents concerning seizure, valuation and sale were sent to addresses where the owner did not live, even though the bailiffs knew he was incarcerated.

The share was sold to a third party.

Our position

We challenged the sale.

The court found substantial procedural violations, invalidated the auction of 14 February 2023 and the sale agreement of 14 March 2023, and ordered the restoration of Nikolay Shchechkin’s ownership of the half share.

Result

The Leninsky District Court of Krasnoyarsk (Ленинский районный суд г. Красноярска) restored the client’s ownership of the 1/2 share in the apartment (case No. 2-267/2024, decision of 28 February 2024).

The claim was granted in part: the court did not find the challenged actions of the state property agency unlawful.

The published information does not confirm whether the restored right has been registered in the property register or whether the judgment has entered into force.

Result

The court restored the client’s ownership of a half share in the apartment

The court found substantial procedural violations, invalidated the auction of 14 February 2023 and the sale agreement of 14 March 2023, and ordered the restoration of Nikolay Shchechkin’s ownership of the half share.

The 1/2 share in the apartment sold at auction was returned to the client’s ownership by court decision.

Our role

Konsultant Law Firm represented the plaintiff, Nikolay Shchechkin (Щечкин Николай Васильевич), who owned a half share in the apartment.

The case was handled by lawyer Viktor Erofeev.

The court declared the bailiffs’ actions in transferring the 1/2 share to auction unlawful, invalidated the auction and the purchase and sale agreement concluded on its results, and restored the client’s ownership.

Court

Leninsky District Court of Krasnoyarsk (Ленинский районный суд г. Красноярска)

Case

No. 2-267/2024

Decision date

28 February 2024

Plaintiff

Shchechkin Nikolay Vasilyevich (Щечкин Николай Васильевич)

Status of client

plaintiff, owner of a 1/2 share in the apartment

Main defendants

FSSP units, Rosimushchestvo, Krotov V.G., OOO «Sever»

Subject of the dispute

declaration of the auction as invalid and restoration of ownership

Object

1/2 ownership share in the apartment

Initial value per the valuation

RUB 296,000

Funds from the sale per the case materials

RUB 986,000

FSSP actions in transferring the share for sale

declared unlawful

Auction of 14 February 2023

declared invalid

Purchase and sale agreement of 14 March 2023

declared invalid

Client’s ownership

restored by the court for the 1/2 share in the apartment

Claim of unlawfulness of Rosimushchestvo’s actions

rejected

Claim

granted in part

Argument about missed deadline

rejected by the court

Actual registration of the restored right in the property register

not confirmed by the provided source

Entry of the judgment into legal force

not confirmed by the provided source

Appeal

not established by the provided source

Lawyer

Viktor Erofeev, Konsultant Law Firm

Practice Areas

Practices Related to This Case

Nikolay Nemkov

Managing Partner, Konsultant Law Firm

Nikolay Nemkov

← All Cases

Have bailiffs seized your property or sold it at auction?

We will review the enforcement file, notices, bailiff orders, the valuation report and its validity period, and the auction and sale documents. We will assess the grounds for challenging the enforcement actions, auction or sale in court.